A More Perfect Union: The Marriage Lesson Hidden in America’s Founding

Dan Purcell

Hi, I’m Dan! I am a professional marriage counselor and coach, with a specialty in helping Christian couples find joy and connection through sexual intimacy. My wife Emily and I are the founders of Get Your Marriage On! We have 6 children and love the outdoors.

Every year around Independence Day, I find myself thinking about the founding of our country.

Not just the fireworks or the parades or the patriotic music.

This year I found myself thinking about a hot, stuffy room in Philadelphia in the summer of 1787.

Fifty-five delegates gathered together to solve an incredibly difficult problem. They represented different states, different interests, different economies, and different ideas about how the country should be governed.

And here’s what fascinates me.

They didn’t agree.

Not even close.

The larger states wanted one thing. The smaller states wanted another. Some wanted a stronger national government. Others worried that too much centralized power would eventually become dangerous.

They argued.

They debated.

Tempers flared.

Yet somehow, out of all of those differences came one of the most remarkable governing documents in history.

As I thought about that this year, I couldn’t help but think about marriage.

Because marriage isn’t all that different.

You marry someone who has different experiences, different expectations, different ways of seeing the world, and often different desires when it comes to intimacy.

One spouse may naturally crave more physical connection.

The other may need emotional closeness before desire even begins to show up.

One loves spontaneity.

The other prefers predictability.

One feels rejected.

The other feels pressured.

Sound familiar?

When couples get stuck, it’s easy to start asking questions like:

“Who’s right?”

“Whose needs matter more?”

“Who needs to change?”

But I wonder if we’re asking the wrong question.

What if the better question is:

“What kind of marriage can hold both of us?”

That’s exactly what happened during the Constitutional Convention.

The breakthrough wasn’t that one side finally defeated the other.

It wasn’t that the large states won.

It wasn’t that the small states won.

Instead, they created an entirely new structure that honored both concerns.

I think that’s one of the greatest lessons we can borrow for marriage.

Sometimes we’re so busy trying to convince our spouse to see things our way that we never stop to ask whether there’s a completely different solution we could build together.

Maybe instead of arguing about spontaneity versus planning, you create a rhythm that includes both.

Maybe instead of fighting over initiation, you create a way for both spouses to communicate desire that feels safe.

Maybe instead of deciding whose needs are more important, you build habits that allow both spouses to feel represented.

That’s collaboration.

And I think collaboration is far more powerful than compromise.

Compromise often feels like both people lose a little.

Collaboration creates something neither person could have created alone.

There’s another lesson from the Constitutional Convention that I love.

Near the end of the convention, Benjamin Franklin encouraged the delegates to “doubt a little of your own infallibility.”

I think that’s wonderful marriage advice.

Imagine beginning a difficult conversation by saying to yourself,

“Maybe I don’t see the whole picture.”

“Maybe my spouse’s experience makes more sense than I realize.”

Humility changes conversations.

Defensiveness usually ends them.

As we celebrate Independence Day, I hope you’ll enjoy the fireworks, the family gatherings, and everything else that makes this holiday special.

But I also hope you’ll spend a few minutes thinking about your own “more perfect union.”

Not a perfect marriage.

Not a perfect sex life.

Not a perfect spouse.

Just two imperfect people who are willing to keep showing up, keep listening, and keep building something better together.

Because that’s what great marriages do.

Not perfectly.

But little by little, they become a more perfect union.

Share This Article?

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Scroll to Top