How to Talk About Fantasies with Your Spouse: A Couples Guide to Sharing Without Fear

Dan Purcell

Hi, I’m Dan! I have a Master’s Degree in Counseling and am a professional marriage coach, with a specialty in helping Christian couples find joy and connection through sexual intimacy. My wife Emily and I are the founders of Get Your Marriage On! We have 6 children and love the outdoors.

Sharing a fantasy with your spouse is one of the most intimate things you can do in a marriage. I’ve worked with a lot of couples who would honestly rather have sex than tell each other what’s going on in their minds. That makes sense. Your body is one thing, but your imagination feels like the most private part of you.

That’s also why it’s worth it. When you let your spouse see that part of you, and they let you see theirs, something opens up between you that a new position or a new outfit can’t touch.

How do you share a fantasy with your spouse? Pick a relaxed, private moment, not in the middle of sex or after an argument. Start small, explain the feeling behind the fantasy rather than just the scenario, and make it clear you’re sharing, not asking for anything. When your spouse shares with you, listen with curiosity instead of judgment. You never have to act on a fantasy for sharing it to bring you closer.

First, What a Fantasy Is (and Isn’t)

A fantasy isn’t a request. This is the single biggest misunderstanding I see. When a spouse hears their partner’s fantasy, they often assume it’s something their partner wants to do. Many fantasies are exciting as an idea and have nothing to do with real life. Someone might fantasize about sex somewhere public because the thought is thrilling, with zero desire to actually do it.

So when you have a fantasy, you get to decide what to do with it. You can:

  • Keep it to yourself.
  • Share it with your spouse and leave it as a fantasy.
  • Share it and play with it in a safe way, like role-play in the privacy of your bedroom.
  • Share it and, if you both want to, try it in real life.

All four are okay. If you want to go deeper on what fantasies are, why they’re normal, and the different kinds men and women tend to have, read my full post on understanding your sexual fantasies.

Why Sharing Fantasies Builds Intimacy

Someone once broke the word intimacy down as “into-me-see.” Real intimacy is letting another person see who you really are.

Dr. David Schnarch, who wrote Passionate Marriage, describes two kinds of intimacy. The first says, “I’ll tell you about me, but only if you make me feel secure and tell me about you too.” The second says, “I don’t expect you to agree with me. I want you to know me.” The first is really about getting validation. The second is about being known.

Sharing fantasies works best from that second place. You’re not sharing so your spouse will approve. You’re sharing because you want them to know you.

Before You Share: Get Clear on Your Why

Ask yourself one honest question: why do I want to share this? If the answer is connection, curiosity or wanting your spouse to know you better, you’re on solid ground. If the answer is “so they’ll finally agree to do it,” slow down. A fantasy shared as a sales pitch usually lands as pressure, and pressure kills passion.

Not sure what your fantasies even are? That’s common, especially for wives. Try this for a week: notice what you find sexually interesting or arousing, like a memory, a movie scene, or a moment with your spouse, and jot it down. One woman told me it wasn’t until she watched her husband stacking chairs after church, joking with an older couple, that it hit her: he’s so hot. That was a fantasy waiting to be noticed. Coach Amy Langford and I dig into this, including what to do when a spouse says they don’t have any fantasies, on episode 244.

How to Bring It Up

  • Pick your moment. Choose a relaxed, private time when you’re both feeling connected. Avoid bringing it up in the middle of sex, when one of you is exhausted, or right after a disagreement.
  • Start small. Share something mild first. You’re building trust, and you can always go further later.
  • Share the feeling, not just the scenario. “I love the idea of you taking the lead because it makes me feel wanted” tells your spouse far more than the scenario alone.
  • Take the pressure off out loud. Make it clear you’re sharing, not asking.

A few ways to open the conversation:

“Hey babe, I’ve been thinking about some things I may want to try to build our connection and add some fun. Can I share them with you and see what you think? If not, I completely understand.”

“Can I tell you something I’ve thought about? I’m not asking us to do it. I just want you to know me.”

“I’ll go first, and you don’t have to share anything back unless you want to.”

The Easiest Way to Start: The Sexploration List

If saying a fantasy out loud feels like too big a jump, start with the Sexploration List inside the Intimately Us app. It works like a yes/no/maybe list. You each go through it privately on your own phone and mark every idea yes, no or maybe. Then the app shows you only the things you both said yes or maybe to.

Anything either of you marked no simply disappears. Nobody has to defend a no, and nobody feels rejected for asking. It turns the scariest part of sharing fantasies into something simple and even fun. Your matches become a ready-made list of things you’re both curious about, and a great starting point for a deeper conversation.

Prefer paper? There’s also a printable Sexploration List, and you can read more about how the yes/no/maybe list works. Or download our free Sexual Fantasy Questionnaire below as a conversation starter.

How to Respond When Your Spouse Shares

How you respond matters even more than how you share. Your reaction decides whether your spouse ever opens up again.

  • Thank them. They just took a real risk.
  • Get curious before you react. “What do you like about that?” or “What does it make you feel?” will teach you more about your spouse than you’d expect.
  • Don’t yuck their yum. You don’t have to share a fantasy to respect that it matters to them.
  • Remember, you’re not agreeing to anything. Listening is not a promise to act.

There’s a scene in A Few Good Men where Jack Nicholson shouts, “You can’t handle the truth!” Some of us build marriages where our spouse can’t tell us the truth, because we shut it down the moment we’re uncomfortable. A Black Belt move is creating a marriage with room for two different people, with two different imaginations.

That includes honoring fantasies that look different from yours. I once watched a husband ask his wife for her fantasies, then dismiss them because they weren’t adventurous enough: “No, that’s not a fantasy, tell me a real one.” He wasn’t listening; he was fishing for what he wanted to hear. Her fantasies carry just as much weight in the marriage as his.

What If It’s a No?

It’s okay to have hard nos. You never have to do anything sexually, in real life or in fantasy, that you don’t want to do. Say it honestly and kindly: “I’m glad you told me. That one isn’t for me.” That’s useful information, and good lovers want to know their spouse’s turn-offs as much as their turn-ons.

If you’re the one hearing no, watch what happens inside you. On episode 266 I walked through a couple stuck in a common loop. He asked to film themselves. She wasn’t comfortable. He felt rejected and pulled away, and she felt pressured to give in to keep the peace, then resented it. Around and around it went.

A better response from him might sound like this: “I can tell you’re not into that idea. Part of me wants to pull away and feel hurt, but what I really want is to know what you honestly think, even if it’s different from me.” That’s what turns a no into intimacy instead of distance.

And if one spouse keeps pushing the same fantasy over and over, it’s worth asking whether it has moved from fantasy into pressure. That’s a conversation to have honestly, and sometimes with help.

From Fantasy to Real Life (If You Both Want To)

If you both feel good about exploring a fantasy together, there are lots of ways to do it at your own comfort level:

It Will Probably Feel Awkward (and That’s Okay)

People ask me all the time how to share fantasies without it feeling awkward. My honest answer: I don’t think it ever stops feeling a little awkward. The goal isn’t to make the awkwardness go away. It’s to grow your ability to tolerate it, so you can show your spouse the more hidden parts of you anyway. That courage is where deeper intimacy comes from.

Sharing Fantasies: Common Questions

How do I tell my spouse my sexual fantasies?

Choose a relaxed, private moment, start with something mild, and focus on the feeling behind the fantasy. Make it clear you’re sharing, not asking. A tool like the Sexploration List in the Intimately Us app can make the first step easier.

Is it okay for Christian couples to share fantasies?

Many Christian couples find that sharing fantasies with each other, privately and with love, deepens their intimacy. A fantasy shared between husband and wife is about knowing each other more fully. Talk about it together and decide what fits your values.

Do I have to act on my spouse’s fantasy?

No. Hearing a fantasy is not agreeing to it. Many fantasies are meant to stay in the imagination, and you can always say no to anything that isn’t right for you.

What if my spouse says they don’t have any fantasies?

That’s common. Many people, especially wives, have never given themselves permission to notice what they find arousing. Spend a week paying attention to moments, memories or scenes that spark desire, or start with a yes/no/maybe list to discover interests together.

What if I’m ashamed of a fantasy?

Trying not to think about something usually makes it stick. Instead, try reframing the fantasy into a version you feel good about, or replacing it with a thought you’re happier with. If it keeps troubling you, talking it through with a coach can help.

If you and your spouse want help with this, or with building a more intimate marriage overall, our coaching program is built for exactly that. And for the bigger picture on talking about sex, see our pillar on sexual communication in marriage.

Share This Article?

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Scroll to Top